How to Evaluate Nonprofit Performance and Set SMART Goals

Nonprofit organizations play a crucial role in tackling social issues and creating positive change in their communities. But tracking progress and ensuring long-term sustainability can be challenging without a well-structured nonprofit evaluation and goal-setting process. 

To successfully navigate this path, nonprofits need to adopt a systematic approach. By analyzing key performance indicators and aligning goals with the organization's mission, nonprofits can unlock the potential of practical evaluation and the power of SMART goal-setting for the year ahead. 

Read on to explore strategies for nonprofit performance evaluation and discover how translating evaluation results into SMART goals paves the way to a brighter future.



What is Nonprofit Performance?

Nonprofit performance refers to the effectiveness and efficiency with which an organization achieves its mission and goals; it’s not solely measured by financial success but also by the impact and outcomes of its programs and initiatives. Evaluating nonprofit performance helps organizations figure out how well they fulfill their purpose and make a positive difference in their communities.


The Importance of Nonprofit Evaluation

Assessing your nonprofit’s performance is crucial for helping you:

  • Understand which programs and initiatives work: By acknowledging the agenda, you can refine your strategies to increase your impact. For example, if a nonprofit focusing on environmental conservation discovers through evaluation that its community engagement programs are more effective in promoting sustainable practices, it can redirect efforts and resources to strengthen those programs further.

  • Determine whether you’re allocating resources efficiently: Performance evaluation helps you determine the efficiency of resource allocation. Analyzing financial data and program outcomes can identify areas where resources are being used optimally and where spending needs to be reined in or reallocated. 

  • Set realistic and measurable objectives: Finally, nonprofit program evaluation is essential because it forms the basis for goal-setting, enabling you to craft practical and measurable goals that align with your mission.

How to Evaluate Nonprofit Performance

Since there’s no one-size-fits-all approach to nonprofit evaluation, choosing the right strategies and methods is important depending on the type of nonprofit you run and its unique activities and objectives. With that in mind, let's explore some general strategies for evaluating nonprofit performance effectively.

Assess Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

Identifying and assessing key performance indicators (KPIs) is a fundamental strategy for nonprofit performance evaluation. By carefully selecting relevant KPIs, you gain insights into specific areas that align with your mission and goals. Setting benchmarks for each KPI also enables you to establish measurable targets and track progress over time, so you can make data-driven decisions and strive for continuous improvement.

It’s vital to ensure you select a variety of KPIs to capture your program’s or initiative’s outcomes fully. To give you an idea, consider a nonprofit organization that offers enrichment classes for underprivileged children in a specific community. One of their KPIs could be the number of children enrolled. By tracking this metric, they can assess whether they successfully reach their target audience. However, another KPI would be needed to measure the impact of the program on enrolled children’s lives. For this, they might look at measures of academic achievement or emotional well-being, like school truancy rates, grades, or other data, depending on what information is available. Choosing KPIs carefully is necessary for accurately measuring program impact. Some of the strategic measures in KPIs that you should consider include:

Analyzing the Financial Performance

Analyzing financial performance is another helpful strategy for nonprofit program evaluation. Reviewing revenue and expenses, evaluating fundraising efforts, and assessing budget allocation provide insights into an organization's financial health and efficiency. 

One commonly used ratio is the “current ratio,” which measures a company’s ability to pay short-term obligations or those due within one year. By comparing current assets to current liabilities, you can determine if you have enough resources to cover immediate financial obligations. And if not, you can take proactive steps to optimize resource allocation, secure additional funding, or adjust spending strategies to establish financial stability and sustainability.

Evaluating the Program's Impact

Evaluating the impact of programs and initiatives is vital to know their effectiveness. You can examine program outcomes and outputs to measure how much your nonprofit has achieved its intended goals. 

For instance, consider a community-based healthcare program that aims to improve maternal and child health. In addition to tracking the number of prenatal check-ups and vaccinations administered, a situational analysis would assess the overall improvement in maternal and infant health indicators within the target population. You become aware of how effectively the program operates by analyzing program efficiency from beginning to end, including resource utilization, processes, timelines, and stakeholder engagement. This holistic evaluation approach empowers you to identify improvement areas and ensure efficient resource allocation.

Engaging Stakeholders in Evaluation

Engaging stakeholders in the nonprofit evaluation process provides valuable perspectives and insights. By involving board members, staff, donors, volunteers, and beneficiaries, you can comprehensively understand your nonprofit performance. 

Consider conducting surveys or interviews with stakeholders and/or organizing focus groups or town hall meetings.  Or: involve stakeholders in the decision-making process through advisory boards or committees. Stakeholders can provide feedback, suggestions, and valuable input, like suggesting new fundraising methods or partnerships to maximize resources and reach a wider audience, which can help shape future strategies and goals.

Continuous Monitoring 

Regularly observing performance and ensuring KPIs are on track enable you to identify areas requiring immediate attention and make course corrections. 

Examine the before, during, and after phases of fundraising events and other activities using a checklist or guide to make certain that everything is running smoothly and goals are being met. This proactive approach empowers your nonprofit to stay on track, adapt to changing circumstances, and maximize your positive impact in the communities you serve.


Download The Checklist


How to Start SMART Goals From Your Nonprofit Evaluation

Now that we’ve evaluated nonprofit performance, it's time to set SMART goals based on the evaluation results. SMART goals are specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound. They provide a clear framework for nonprofits to work towards their desired outcomes. Remember, it’s important to relate your SMART goals to the results of nonprofit performance evaluation to develop better plans for the following year.

Here are just a few examples of how to set SMART goals: 

  • Engage and Educate: Identify specific and measurable goals that align with your mission and vision, such as increasing the number of involved beneficiaries or the level of awareness about your cause.

  • Optimize Resources: Consider available resources and capabilities to check if your goals are achievable and realistic. Let’s say your nonprofit aims to improve community health, so you should set a goal to provide regular health check-ups for 500 community members in a year, confirming that your staff and funding can support this effort.
  • Measure Impact: Review if your goals are relevant to your nonprofit’s overall performance and directly impact its success. An appropriate goal for a nonprofit focused on environmental conservation could be to reduce carbon emissions by a certain percentage through tree-planting initiatives and sustainable practices.
  • Track Progress: Set a timeline for achieving each goal, breaking them down into smaller milestones or targets to track progress effectively. For instance, if your nonprofit aims to raise $50,000 a year for a specific project, establish quarterly fundraising targets and monitor donations regularly to secure that you are on track to reach the overall goal.

Free guide: 7 Key CRM Features to Engage More Donors


Why Is It Important to Set SMART Goals?

SMART goals provide clarity and direction, keeping staff and volunteers motivated and focused on achieving desired outcomes. By regularly reviewing and adjusting plans, you can stay on track, measure progress, and make sure that your efforts align with your nonprofit’s mission and vision. 

Having weak or vague goals, or no goals at all, may lead to disorganized efforts and a lack of progress. So, instead of leaving your nonprofit's success to chance, embrace the power of SMART goals and consistent evaluation to drive it towards a more significant impact and fulfillment of its purpose. With a clear roadmap and a commitment to improvement, your nonprofit can confidently navigate the challenges ahead and make a meaningful difference in the communities you serve.


Master Your Nonprofit Evaluation and Planning With FrontStream

If you're looking to improve your nonprofit's performance, our digital, all-in-one fundraising and donor management solution can help. With features like dynamic reporting and SmartLists – plus unlimited constituent records, emailing, fundraising events, and more – our platform makes every step of evaluating, measuring, enacting, and exceeding performance goals easier than ever. 


Schedule a demo with an expert today!

Share this article